This site is new, so we will not pretend otherwise: the testimonials below are verifiable third-party results about the pans we cover, not invented quotes about us. As reader mail arrives, real reader experiences will be added here, with permission and never fabricated.
Independent recognition of pans we list
America’s Test Kitchen
Named the Mauviel M’Steel its top carbon steel skillet after months of testing that included laboratory checks for metal safety. We list the 11 inch.
4.7 from 11,316 reviews
Made In’s carbon steel holds one of the largest published buyer-review bases in the category. We quote both the average and the recurring complaints.
CNN Underscored & Food Network
Both name de Buyer among the best carbon steel pans of 2026 in tested roundups. The MINERAL B Pro is the version we list.
What we hope to earn from you
The testimonials that matter most to a site like this are corrections that made a page more accurate, and ownership reports from cooks months into a pan we recommended. If a guide here helped you choose well, or saved you from choosing badly, tell us and say whether we may print your words with your first name.
Our standing policy on testimonials
Everything on this page is checkable. We do not publish anonymous praise we cannot verify, we do not commission reviews, and we do not edit reader quotes beyond spelling. If that means this page grows slowly, we are comfortable with slow.